THE BALANCEhttps://thebalance.clinic/about/publications/press/dazed-hope-privilege-positive-thinking/
THE BALANCE

Private admissions

Let’s talk about your next step.

Speak with our admissions team about treatment for you or someone you care about.

Your admissions team

Jil Moore
Jil MooreClient Relations Director
Cynthia Nakhle
Cynthia NakhleAdmissions Manager
Abdullah Boulad, Founder & CEO

Prefer to speak with our founder?

Abdullah Boulad · Founder & CEO

Dazed · Editorial reflections

Keeping hope in touch with reality

A thoughtful response to lucky girl syndrome, with room for opportunity, unequal circumstances, and feelings that do not fit a positive script.

Original publicationRead the original article
DazedReported feature

Is It Lucky Girl Syndrome or Is It Just Privilege?

Article by Emma Kershaw · January 19, 2023

Emma Kershaw’s Dazed feature includes commentary from Abdullah Boulad, identified as founder of THE BALANCE, on the limits of positive thinking.

Hope can be useful without being a theory of how the universe works. A person may approach an application with more willingness, notice an invitation they would otherwise dismiss, or feel encouraged by a sentence they repeat to themselves. The difficulty begins when encouragement becomes a promise that thoughts determine outcomes, or when disappointment is treated as evidence that someone believed incorrectly.

Dazed’s feature on lucky girl syndrome includes commentary from THE BALANCE founder Abdullah Boulad about the limits of positive thinking. This original article considers the broader cultural question: how can people remain open to possibility while acknowledging chance, unequal circumstances, and feelings that cannot be improved on command?

The phrase is a social media label, not a medical diagnosis. It is best approached as a claim to examine rather than a condition to identify in yourself. What matters is whether a practice supports useful choices and leaves room for the truth of your situation, including the parts that are difficult to change.

Four questions to prepare

  1. Does this belief encourage a useful action or promise an outcome outside my control?

  2. Which resources or opportunities are missing from the success story I am comparing with?

  3. Can I acknowledge disappointment without treating it as a personal failure?

  4. What support would make the next step more possible in my actual circumstances?

Separate encouragement from an explanation of events

An encouraging sentence can be valuable as a personal cue. Someone might use it before introducing themselves at an event or sending work to an editor. In that setting, its purpose is to help them begin. It does not explain why an opportunity is offered, why another applicant is chosen, or why circumstances change after the application is sent.

Consider two people who repeat the same affirmation before applying for a role. They may have different qualifications, access to references, time to prepare, and responsibilities outside work. The employer’s priorities may also be unknown. The outcome cannot tell us which person thought more positively. Treating it as a test of belief discards most of the information needed to understand what happened.

Keep the statement close to something you can do. You might remind yourself that an application is worth making or that you can ask a question despite uncertainty. This preserves an element of choice without claiming control over other people’s decisions. If the result is disappointing, the next conversation can then concern feedback, fit, or another opportunity, rather than whether you somehow caused rejection by having doubts.

Look for the context outside the frame

A short success story rarely contains every resource that supported it. There may have been savings, introductions, reliable transportation, flexible work, or someone caring for children. Recognizing those conditions does not require dismissing the person’s effort. It makes the story more informative. Advice becomes easier to evaluate when the practical conditions are visible.

The World Health Organization identifies social and environmental circumstances, including poverty, violence, and inequality, among the factors that shape mental health. An individual’s outlook exists within that wider setting. It should not be asked to carry responsibility for conditions that require material support, institutional change, or collective action.

When a story invites comparison, ask what you do and do not know. A creator’s travel schedule may reveal little about their income or assistance. A business announcement may omit years of unpaid preparation. Use the story to discover a possible route, then check whether that route fits your resources. Where a gap exists, name it accurately. Needing time, access, money, or accommodation is a practical issue to address, not a defect in confidence.

Let difficult feelings have a legitimate place

Optimism becomes demanding when every uncomfortable feeling has to be corrected immediately. Disappointment after a rejection, anger about unfair treatment, or grief after a loss does not automatically indicate a harmful outlook. These experiences may call for attention, company, or practical help. A person should not have to present them in an uplifting form before others will listen.

In a conversation with a friend, ask what kind of response they want. They may want to describe what happened before considering options. They may want help writing a message or identifying a service. An automatic reminder to stay positive can miss either request. Listening carefully allows encouragement to arrive at a useful moment, with a purpose the person recognizes.

You can also give yourself permission to hold more than one feeling. A new opportunity may be exciting and uncertain. A decision to change direction may bring relief and sadness. There is no need to decide which feeling is the correct one before making a practical plan. If emotional distress persists or makes everyday life difficult, seek appropriate professional support. A trend should not discourage a conversation about care.

Read success stories with ordinary questions

When someone says a method changed everything, ask what changed, over what period, and what else happened. Did they begin applying for roles, meet new collaborators, or acquire a qualification? Those actions may be relevant even if the storyteller prefers a more dramatic explanation. You can learn from concrete steps without accepting every claim attached to them.

Look for what the story leaves out. How many attempts received no reply? Which plans were abandoned? Would an unsuccessful experience be as likely to appear in a celebratory post? These questions help you recognize that a feed is a selection of accounts, not a complete record of all attempts and outcomes. You do not need to assume dishonesty to notice that the available information is incomplete.

Be especially careful when a personal story becomes a sales argument. Ask what a course or membership actually provides, what it costs, and whether the promised result can reasonably be guaranteed. A purchase should be evaluated on its concrete content and terms. Feeling that you must buy something to demonstrate faith in yourself is a reason to pause and examine the offer more closely.

Build agency around a specific next step

Choose one situation in which you would like more room to act. Perhaps you want to approach a potential mentor, attend a class, or ask about a workplace adjustment. Describe the first step in terms that can be completed and observed. Then identify what would make it possible: information, time, transport, an introduction, or a person willing to practice the conversation with you.

Imagine someone hoping to change careers while supporting a family. A declaration that opportunities will arrive may feel encouraging, but the schedule still needs attention. They might begin by asking a training provider about evening options and financial assistance. The information could reveal a workable route, or show that the timing is currently difficult. Either answer is more useful than treating uncertainty as a sign to believe harder.

Include a response to obstacles. If a message receives no reply, decide whether and when to follow up. If a course is unaffordable, identify another route or revisit the timing. Adjustments do not erase the original intention. They show that the plan is responding to information. Hope can remain present while the method changes, the deadline moves, or the goal itself becomes more precise. A group can also ask what it is willing to provide, rather than telling individuals to improve their outlook. At work, that might mean explaining promotion criteria, opening access to training, or making an accommodation process easier to understand. Among friends, it might mean sharing information about an opportunity instead of describing the person who found it as uniquely fortunate. These actions do not require agreement about every theory of success. They make a resource more available. When encouragement is paired with an actual offer, name the offer clearly and let the recipient decide whether it is useful. Hope becomes more credible when people can point to something concrete that has changed in their circumstances and everyday working life.

Practice hope without making it a verdict

The way we discuss success affects how we respond to other people’s difficulties. If every favorable outcome is explained by mindset, setbacks can begin to look like failures of attitude. A more generous account recognizes effort, support, chance, and circumstance together. It leaves room to congratulate someone without implying that everyone else could obtain the same result by thinking differently.

In a group or family, try celebrating specific actions as well as outcomes. Someone may have asked a difficult question, prepared carefully, or maintained a boundary even when the result was not what they wanted. Those actions can matter without becoming consolation prizes. Ask what they learned and what they would like to do next, if anything, before supplying another challenge.

For your own life, choose a form of hope that can survive new information. It can mean being willing to ask, accepting support, or keeping more than one possible future in view. It can also include rest when circumstances demand it. A useful outlook makes room for reality and helps you respond to it; it does not require you to take responsibility for everything that happens.

YOU MAY FIND THESE HELPFUL

Start here.

THE BALANCE
A PLACE TO BEGIN

Ask about our care